Search Sports Card Radio

Sports Trading Card Price Tracker We talk a lot about price movement of single cards and sports trading card boxes on The Sports Card Show Podcast. Each month we'll pick some hot items in the sports card world and monitor the price action over the month. Sometimes we make prediction on if the price is going to go up or down.
User Rating:  / 1

 Even though Derek Jeter is retired - his rookie cards are still collected 
as much as they ever have. Finding one's in good condition can
increase the value more & more.

 

1993 Upper Deck SP Foil #279

BGS 9.5 (9.5 9.5 10 9.5 Subs)
A Derek Jeter SP rookie that was 1 point from BGS 10 sold for $13,200 - the best offer was accepted by the seller who was asking $18,000. Most other Jeter SP rookies graded BGS 9.5 sell for much less.
BGS 9.5 - $1,375 - $2,250
PSA 9 - $775 - $1,310
PSA 8.5 - $295 - $340
PSA 8 - $100 - $190
PSA 7 - $65 - $110
PSA 6.5 - $60 - $70
1993 Upper Deck SP Derek Jeter Rookie SP PSA 9
   
1993 Pinnacle #457

Much like the 1993 Upper Deck SP - there's a premium paid for Pinnacle Derek Jeter rookie cards in good condition, as the value falls off sharply from a PSA 10 Gem Mint to one in just Mint condition.
BGS 10 - $3,380
BGS 9.5 - $100 - $245
PSA 10 - $200 - $325
BCCG 10 - $45 - $65
PSA 9 - $30 - $45
PSA 8.5 - $25 - $30
PSA 8 - $12 - $22
1993 Pinnacle Derek Jeter Rookie PSA 9
   

1993 Topps #98 

Florida Marlins & Colorado Rockies Inaugural Edition
- These cards only came inside specially marked factory sets. The easist way to tell if you have a Marlins Inagural Season Rookie, there's a foil stamp placed over Jeter's right leg. On the Rockies version, the foil stamp is above Jeter's left foot. Only 5,000 of each cards was made.

BGS 10 - $2,000
BGS 9.5 - $75 - $150
PSA 10 - $80 - $175

Marlins & Rockies

PSA 10 - $345 - $425
BGS 9.5 - $250 - $270 
PSA 10 - $250 - $340
PSA 9 - $85 - $100
1993 Topps Derek Jeter Rookie #98 Graded PSA 9
   
1993 Topps Stadium Club Murphy #117

These cards are found in 1993 Topps Stadium Club Dome Factory Sets - which still sell sealed online. The stated print run for these sets was 128,000.
PSA 10 - $275 - $345
BGS 9.5 - $165 - $275
PSA 9 - $105 - $155
PSA 8 - $85 - $95
1993 Topps Stadium Club Murphy Derek Jeter RC #117 PSA 9
   

1993 Bowman #511

Bowman Rookie Cards are often a baseball player's best rookie - but for Derek Jeter, that really ins't the case. Still a very nice card to have - but unlike some of Jeter's condition sensitive rookies - the 1993 Bowman version only has a value premium when graded in Gem Mint condition.

BGS 9.5 - $90 - $180
PSA 10 - $90 - $165
PSA 9 - $20 - $40
1993 Bowman Derek Jeter Rookie Card #511 BGS 9.5
   

1993 Score #489

Actually the least valuable out of Derek Jeter's main stream MLB rookie card releases. Might be considered the 'poor mans' Derek Jeter rookie card if you are a collector on a budget - it might make a nice choice.

PSA 10 - $40 - $115
BGS 9.5 - $35 - $100
PSA 9 - $18 - $25
1993 Score #489 Derek Jeter Rookie Card Graded BGS 9.5 Gem Mint
   
   
1993 Score Select #360

BGS 9.5 - $59 - $135
PSA 10 - $59 - $75
PSA 9 - $15 - $27
1993 Score Select Derek Jeter Rookie Card #360 Graded PSA 10 Gem Mint
   
   
1993 Upper Deck #449

BGS 9.5 - $56 - $125
PSA 10 - $60 - $115
PSA 9 - $15 - $29

'Gold Hologram' Version

BGS 9.5 - $650
PSA 9 - $475
BGS 9 - $300
PSA 8 - $180
1993 Upper Deck #449 Derek Jeter Rookie Card Graded PSA 9
User Rating:  / 0

2001 Topps Archives Reserve #69 - Robin Roberts - Courtesy of COMC.com

Sold For $0.50 - Date Sold: 1/1/2015

2001 Topps Archives Reserves
Robin Roberts
Card #69

User Rating:  / 0
   

2004 Leaf Limited #120 - Jim Thorpe /799 - Courtesy of COMC.com

Sold For $0.75 - Date Sold: 1/1/2015

2004 Leaf Limited
Jim Thorpe
Card #120
Serial Numbered #/799